Insurance Carriers – Claim Reporting Contact Information American Property Insurance (A.P.I.) (848)-208-2000 CNA (929)-186-1173 CNA SURETY (866)-883-7692 CHUBB (800)-252-4670 Cumberland Mutual (856)-451-4050 Cure (800)-229-9151 Farmers of Salem (800)-498-0954 Franklin Mutual Insurance (800)-336-3642 Great Bay Insurance Group (609)-535-8000 Hanover Insurance Group (800)-628-0250 Main Street America (877)-927-5672 Nationwide (866)-854-4140 Plymouth Rock (844)-346-1225 Philadelphia Insurance Company (800)-765-9749 Selective Insurance (866)-455-9969 The-Hartford (860)-547-5000 Travelers Personal Lines (800)-252-4633 Travelers Commercial Lines (800)-238-6225 Zurich (800)-255-3612